The U.S. Senate voted 51-27 on Thursday, Nov. 12, to end debate on the nomination of Colorado-based U.S. District Judge Daniel Domenico to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, according to the Senate's daily press record. That vote was on cloture, a procedural step. It is not the confirmation vote, which the Senate record says will come "at a time to be determined."

Where the nomination stands

  • The Senate's floor log lists the Domenico vote as a party-line vote of 51-27. Senator John Hickenlooper of Colorado is among the senators listed as not voting.
  • The Senate Judiciary Committee advanced the nomination 12-10 on a party-line vote on July 23, according to the Denver Gazette.
  • The Senate also invoked cloture that day on a Fifth Circuit nominee, Anna St. John. Under the agreement recorded Nov. 12, confirmation votes on both nominations come at a time yet to be set. The same record shows other cloture motions ripening at 5:30 p.m. on Monday, Nov. 16.
  • The current Congress ends on Jan. 3, and senators spoke on Nov. 12 about the work still to finish before then, according to the same floor log.

Why it matters in Colorado

The 10th Circuit is the last stop for most federal cases from Colorado and five neighboring states. Its rulings bind every federal court in that region, the Gazette reported, and few cases go beyond it. A seat on it carries more weight than the district court seat Domenico holds now. Bennet made the same point in June, saying an appellate judgeship is "fundamentally different from and more consequential than" a trial judgeship.

Domenico, now chief judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, was nominated to the seat being vacated by Judge Timothy Tymkovich, a George W. Bush appointee and Domenico's former boss. If confirmed, he would join two of President Trump's first-term appointees on the court, Judges Allison Eid of Colorado and Joel Carson of New Mexico, the Gazette reported.

Colorado's two Democratic senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, said in June they would not support him. Hickenlooper's office cited Domenico's refusal at his June 24 hearing to say who won the 2020 presidential election, and his immigration rulings. Bennet cited Domenico's decision upholding detention without a bond hearing, which he said was at odds with every other federal district judge and magistrate judge in Colorado, and noted he had voted to confirm Domenico to the trial court in 2019.

Their opposition does not decide the outcome. The Senate honors "blue slips," which let home-state senators block a nominee, only for district court nominees, not for the circuit courts, the Gazette reported. The nomination now turns on the Senate floor, where Thursday's 51-27 vote on cloture ran along party lines. Colorado's senators can vote no and argue against him. They cannot stop the seat from being filled.

For Coloradans, the practical stake is how the court will treat the kind of case Domenico has already ruled on. His immigration detention decision is the example both senators pointed to. Appeals of rulings like it are heard by the 10th Circuit. The Gazette's editorial board has urged the Senate to confirm Domenico. That is an opinion, and this story does not adopt it.

What to watch

The next step is a confirmation vote, which the Senate record sets for a time to be determined. We will update this story when the Senate records the result.

Sources